The Coalition Advocating for Adequately Labeled Medicines (CAALM)* has recently filed a Citizen Petition requesting the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) update product labeling for the Pfizer and Moderna Covid vaccines. 

The petition outlines ten points covering safety and efficacy concerns and calls on the FDA to update the product labeling which is seriously out of date and to alert prescribers via Dear Health Care Provider (DHCP) letters. The ten points are as follows: 

  1. Add language clarifying that phase III trials were not designed to determine and failed to provide substantial evidence of vaccine efficacy against SARS-CoV-2 transmission or death. 
  2. Add language clarifying that the immunobridging surrogate endpoint used in multiple authorized indications has not been validated to predict clinical efficacy.
  3. Add safety and efficacy results data from manufacturer randomized trials of current bivalent boosters that reported results after EUA was granted. 
  4. Add a clear statement that FDA authorized a new Pfizer vaccine formulation containing Tris buffer without requiring clinical studies to evaluate efficacy, safety or bioequivalence to the formulation containing phosphate buffer. 
  5. Add a clear statement disclosing that a Pfizer phase III randomized trial in pregnant women (NCT04754594) was completed as of July 2022 but there have been no results reported. 
  6. Add a clear statement that Pfizer vaccine efficacy wanes after 2 months following dose 2 according to the Pfizer phase III randomized trial. 
  7. The following adverse event types should be added to the Adverse Reactions section of labeling:
    • multisystem inflammatory syndrome (MIS) in children; 
    • pulmonary embolism; 
    • sudden cardiac death; 
    • neuropathic and autonomic disorders. 
  8. The following reproductive health and lactation related adverse event types should be added to the Adverse Reactions section of labeling:
    • decreased sperm concentration; 
    • heavy menstrual bleeding; 
    • detection of vaccine mRNA in breastmilk. 
  9. Add frequency data for clinical and subclinical myocarditis. 
  10. Labeling should present trial results on serious adverse events in tables with statistics, as is done for non-serious adverse events. 

Each point is backed by robust evidence and this is clearly referenced within the petition

Subscription Form | Article Bottom CTA

Subscribe to World Council for Health’s newsletter to get up-to-date information about this

Tell the FDA: Update Product Labeling for C19 Vaccines

World Council for Health joins CAALM in its request to the FDA to update product labeling, and invites everyone to submit comments to the FDA here. The FDA has 150 days to respond to the petition. 

The FDA’s stated mission includes ‘protecting the public health by ensuring the safety, efficacy, and security of human and veterinary drugs, biological products and medical devices.’ This is an opportunity for the FDA to fulfill this mission by acting according to the evidence presented. In doing so, it may begin to repair public trust by informing people of the grave risks associated with these experimental gene therapies, misleadingly called ‘vaccines’. 

WCH reminds the FDA and all regulatory agencies around the world that informed consent is an inalienable and universal human right and any person or organisation failing to honour and uphold this right will be held liable. 

In the meantime, World Council for Health reiterates its call for all Covid-19 injections to be stopped immediately, since the evidence – including that cited within CAALM’s Citizen Petition – indicates that these experimental gene therapies are causing immeasurable harm. 

*CAALM is a coalition of current and former FDA advisors and academic researchers from around the US, including drug safety advocate Kim Witczak, Professor Peter Doshi, Professor Martin Makaray, Dr Vinay Prasad and Professor Linda Wastilla. A full list of signatories is included on page 17 of the petition. 

We are a people-powered platform for world health representing 190+ coalition partners in more than 49 countries.

Creative Commons License
Free Cultural Work

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License and is available for republishing and use as a Free Cultural Work.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. All people have the right to know everything about a drug and/or vaccine that is to be administered, so they can make an informed consent! If this cannot be done, 100% honestly, then people will have forever lost their trust in our medical leadership! Do the right thing! Every day and for everyone!!!

  2. Can we add to this petition a request for a clear statement that the dose of the mRNA product does not tell the consumer how much of the biologically active substance (S-protein) will be induced in their body?

    I tried commenting on the FDA website just now and was not able to.